Blog

# The Quest for 700: Weekly GMAT Challenge (Answer)

Yesterday, Manhattan GMAT posted a 700 level GMAT question on our blog. Today, they have followed up with the answer:

In this overlapping sets problem, there are two kinds of sandwiches (tuna melts and veggie melts, abbreviated T and V). There are also two kinds of customers: male and female. Since each customer buys exactly one sandwich, customers and sandwiches are interchangeable. Thus, we can set up one table to keep track of both type of sandwich and type of customer, as follows:

[]        M          F          Total
T
V
Total                            300

We are looking for the ratio of two numbers on this chart: veggie melts bought by females and the total number of veggie melts.

Statement (1): INSUFFICIENT. We can fill in the chart’s total row and total columns, but the four cells in the upper left remain unknown.

[]        M          F      Total
T                                 150 (1/2 of 300)
V                                 150
Total   100       200      300
(1/3 of 300)

Thus, we cannot figure out the needed ratio.

Statement (2): INSUFFICIENT. We can use the relationship between “female tuna melts” and “male veggie melts,” introducing a variable as follows:

[]        M          F          Total
T                     2x
V         x
Total                               300

Statements (1) and (2) together: SUFFICIENT. Combining the tables above, we get the following:

[]        M          F      Total
T                      2x      150
V          x                    150
Total   100      200       300

We can fill in the remaining cells with expressions — for instance, “female veggie melts” can be written as 150 – x, since the veggie row must sum to 150. Now we can add up the female column and solve for x:
2x + (150 – x) = 200
x + 150 = 200
x = 50

Thus, the completed chart looks like this:

[]        M          F          Total
T        50         100       150
V        50         100       150
Total  100        200       300

We see that 100/150, or 2/3, of the veggie melts sold yesterday were bought by female customers.

Note that we could have addressed this problem without knowing the total number of customers (300). We are only looking for a ratio between two numbers on the chart.

The correct answer is (C): Both statements together are sufficient, but neither statement alone is sufficient.